Annulment or Divorce?Clients often ask if they can get their marriage annulled, instead of a divorce.  Usually, this is when they have been married for only a short time and have realized that they have made a mistake and want to undo it.  Let’s examine the two concepts and look at whether an annulment might be possible.

A divorce and an annulment are two fundamentally different things. A divorce is a court ruling that ends a marriage and frees the ex-spouses to legally marry again. Depending on the circumstances, the divorce judgment may also include corollary relief on custody, child support and spousal support. The fundamental precondition to getting a divorce is that the couple must have been legally married. In other words, there must be a valid marriage which is being terminated by the Court. A common law couple, for example, cannot get divorced because they were never married.

An annulment is a judicial ruling that what looked like a marriage, even if there was a marriage certificate, was never a valid marriage. An annulment does not end a marriage; it merely recognizes that there was never a marriage in the first place.

There are only very limited grounds for obtaining an annulment. These are the main ones:

  1. Bigamy – where one of the spouses was still legally married to someone else at the time of the marriage being annulled.
  2. Mental Incapacity – where one or both of the spouses lacks the mental capacity to marry. This would include situations where a person is severely mentally ill, senile, or under the influence of drugs and alcohol to the point where they do not understand what they are agreeing to and lack the mental capacity to enter into a marriage. The law on this issue, and what constitutes sufficient mental capacity to get married is very complex and beyond the scope of this article.
  3. Physical Impotence – An inability to ever consummate the marriage through sexual intercourse. The key here is an inability to have sex, not an unwillingness to do so.

Most people do not meet any of these criteria. When they get married, they can only end the marriage by getting divorced. Even if they realized they made a horrible mistake the next day, an annulment is usually not an option. However if they are lucky they may be able to get an uncontested divorce and deal with things with affidavit evidence instead of having to go to Court.

Robert Pellizzaro

Robert Pellizzaro

Robert Pellizzaro is a lawyer and partner in the firm of Mayer Dearman & Pellizzaro. He has extensive experience practicing divorce and family law.

About Salient

The Castle
Unit 345
2500 Castle Dr
Manhattan, NY

T: +216 (0)40 3629 4753